Original caption: They work even better if you take them with our experimental placebo booster, which I keep in the same bottle.
Monday, June 8, 2015
In Case You Missed It - Placebo Blocker
Original caption: They work even better if you take them with our experimental placebo booster, which I keep in the same bottle.
Thursday, February 26, 2015
Apology and Explanation:
Thanks to all of those who have sent notes asking about my disappearance and offering support.
I plan on adding to the posts on MA Focus, and in the next couple of months moving this blog over to my company’s new website.
Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Slightly OffTopic: NEJM Article on BioPharma Research Credibility
In the study, researchers presented 503 board-certified internists with three random studies with a high, medium and low level of methodological rigor. And then randomly assigned each study one of three funding sources: NIH, Biopharma Industry, Not Disclosed.
The good news is that respondents generally assigned stronger credibility to studies with stronger methodologies.
The difficult news is that the internists believed the results of industry-sponsored were less credible than those that were NIH funded and with no funding disclosed. And that results remained the same whether the study was of high rigor or low rigor. Since the funding source was randomly assigned its clear that simply associating industry funding reduced credibility.
And the kicker – over 75% of the respondents accept support from industry in some manner, so these are not a bunch of ivory tower purists throwing stones. These are exactly the people that MA needs to educate and these are exactly the kinds of studies that we use for that education. Clearly we have a problem.
In an editorial that accompanies the study entitled Believe the Data, Dr. Jeffery Drazen suggests that physicians need to focus on the data and the rigor of developing that data. As an industry, we need to echo that exact point.
We know where this skepticism comes from - too many newspaper stories of incomplete study disclosures, too many studies that seemed to lack rigor, too much willingness to spin results.
We cannot ignore this issue. We need to hit it head on – discussing this now proven bias and why it should not impact the interpretation of results for a given study due to its rigor, etc.
Something that many of us have suspected for awhile, that industry science was being discounted simply because of funding, is now shown to be true. We must address it openly because like any bias when it is pointed out to people they are less likely to be prey to it.
What do you think we can do to address anti-industry bias? Leave your thoughts in the comments section.
Thursday, September 6, 2012
OffTopic: JAMA Article on Accelerated Review
What are your thoughts on the topic? Have we both drunk the industry kool-aid?
Tuesday, July 24, 2012
OffTopic: The FDA Monitoring and Whistleblowing Scandal
The Setting:
Late in the 2nd Bush Admin, at the Center for Devices and Radiological Health (CDRH)
The Baseline Concern:
Some first-line reviewers felt that computer-aided cancer screening diagnostics should not have been approved for use based on their interpretation of the risks associated with by-product radiation and their lack of confidence in the data within the application
The Baseline Grievance:
The first-line reviews saw their recommendations overturned by their senior management, who granted approval.
The Work to Resolve the Grievance:
The first-line reviews complained to Office of Special Counsel (OSC), OIG, members of Congress and eventually to the New York Times about the situation.
OK, already a nightmare but at least fairly clear. Government employees are permitted under the law to ignore certain confidentiality requirements if the safety of the public is at risk. They are not, however, allowed to disclose non-safety related confidential information publically. This is where the first line may have been crossed.
The NY Times Gets Involved:
The NY Times publishes an article describing the situation and including certain confidential information contained in the application and that may not have been directly related to safety concerns.
The Companies React:
The companies whose confidential information is now plastered over the front page of the NY Times demands that this stop.
FDA Senior Management Reacts:
FDA senior management arranges to have the FDA-issued computers of a number of potential leakers secretly monitored – every website visit, every key stroke, every file downloaded.
Quick aside: to be fair to the FDA, every time an employee logs onto their FDA computer they are forced to read the following “You have no reasonable expectation of privacy regarding any communications or data transiting or stored on this information system….” Seems to me its hard to argue that they did not have fair warning.
FDA Senior Management Finds the Leakers/Whistleblowers:
Some of those first-line responders are clearly found to be communicating with the NY Times and other media outlets. They also find correspondence with Congress, OSC and OIG.
FDA Senior Management Terminates the Leakers/Whistleblowers:
Over the next couple of years the contracts of the leakers were not renewed.
Leakers/Whistleblowers Sue FDA for Wrongful Termination:
A lawsuit is, of course, already pending on this.
So far this is a really sad situation, but at least understandable. Now, however, its all about to blow up.
FDA Contractor Screws Up Big Time:
An FDA document management vendor makes a world-class screw up – posting thousand of pages of information that was secretly captured from the computer monitoring on an unsecured website. A terminated leaker/whistleblower discovers this accidentally while Googling her own name.
Everyone Blows a Gasket:
With the documents revealed, all sorts of groups blow a gasket. The leakers/whistleblowers claim their rights were infringed. Congress is furious because some of the communication that was monitored included communication to Congress. The OSC and the OIG are very upset because some of the communication was to them. Neither Congress nor OSC/OIG communications are supposed to be monitored.
And this is where we are today.
Frankly, this whole situation is a major fiasco. It makes the FDA look like the most dysfunctional organization in the government, and that is saying something. Clearly CDRH needs to be stripped down to the floorboards and rebuilt with a functional culture.
Why am I taking a “blame everyone” perspective instead of supporting the leakers/whistleblowers. Normally that would be where my heart was at, but it was just released that those same leakers/whistleblowers had filed a secret lawsuit in court against the manufacturers whose products they felt were unsafe. And this lawsuit was filed while those leakers/whistleblowers were still employed by the FDA reviewing exactly these products. And those same leakers/whistleblowers demanded at least 15% of what would be a multi-billion dollar settlement. Not what you would consider an impartial set of reviewers.
So, this is a pox on both houses situation. We deserve and should expect better from the FDA.
What do you think? Anything I missed? Leave your comments below.